Tuchel Refuses to Name England No 1 After Trafford’s Double Save
Table of Contents
- James Trafford started ahead of Jordan Pickford and made a double save in stoppage time as England beat Spain 3-2 in Madrid, per BBC Sport.
- Thomas Tuchel says England have no number one goalkeeper, a week after making clear Pickford held the role.
- Trafford, 24, has five England caps, all in 2026; Pickford, 32, has 94.
Two Goalkeepers, One Shirt and a Manager Who Will Not Pick a Side
“There’s no No 1,” Thomas Tuchel said, and with that line England’s manager handed the country a debate he declined to settle. James Trafford, the 24-year-old Leeds goalkeeper, started ahead of Jordan Pickford against world champions Spain on Sunday and finished the night mobbed by his teammates after a double save in stoppage time. England won 3-2 in Madrid in the Nations League. It was the first time Spain had lost in the city in 39 years and their first defeat in 43 matches. Last week Tuchel had made clear that Pickford was his number one. After full time he said nobody holds the shirt.
How Trafford Earned the Argument
For an hour, Trafford had almost nothing to do. Spain had not registered a shot on target when Elliot Anderson was sent off in the 63rd minute, and his only work was goal kicks and passes. Then the red shirts swarmed, and the shots came in a flurry.
In the 74th minute he denied Fermin Lopez after a corner. He could do little about Spain’s second goal, a close-range finish from Nico Williams after a centre from Lamine Yamal, but he stayed alert to save from Yamal soon after. He then got to his feet to stop Marc Cucurella’s angled shot creeping in. The biggest moment came in stoppage time, when he dived to his right and then made a second save immediately afterwards.
Declan Rice said: “Everything happened so quick so for him to make two in the space of two seconds is massive,” and added: “A massive night for him.” Spain coach Luis de la Fuente said: “We did generate some chances but England’s goalkeeper has produced a fantastic performance and stopped two or three potential goals in the last 10 or 15 minutes.”
Roy Keane had backed the selection before kick-off. “I think it’s smart management,” he said. “This is the perfect time for Trafford to come in, against top players, and show what he’s capable of doing.” As a pundit, he marvelled at the speed of Trafford’s reflexes: “Every time you watch goalkeepers doing drills, it’s that, making the save and then the reaction,”
Tuchel said afterwards: “He had a brilliant match,” and in his press conference he added: “Very good,” and then: “That’s his job, to close the gap. We want competition in all positions.” Tuchel also set a condition: “We need to see Trafford in high-pressure moments.” Then the manager named the save he rated highest: “The obvious save, where he deserves full credit, is the double save at the very end. Absolutely brilliant.”
Tuchel also praised the goalkeeper’s work in possession. “There was a lot to do in the deep build-up as well, which he did very, very well, with everyone around him.” The manager went on: “Never lose the concentration, never lose the focus, never lose the vision where to find the free men to overcome the press and put the game to the opponent’s half.” And: “With everyone else, he was part of a fantastic team performance.”
The Numbers Behind the Debate
Trafford and Pickford have rotated. Pickford started against Czech Republic and against Croatia twice. Trafford played against Czech Republic and started both matches against Spain, including the home game against Spain in September. All five of his caps came in 2026.
His club form backs him up. Trafford ranks first among the 52 goalkeepers who have played at least 10 games in Europe’s big five leagues for save percentage, at 81.4%. Opta data puts him top of all Premier League goalkeepers for goals prevented this season: eight conceded for Leeds from shots worth 12.40 expected goals, a score of 4.40. Pickford also has a positive differential, with 10 goals conceded from shots worth 11.05 expected goals. “There’s not much between them,” Keane said.
The Case for Pickford
Pickford is 32 and has won 94 caps from his debut in a 0-0 draw with Germany in 2017, which puts him behind only Peter Shilton among England’s most-capped goalkeepers. Opta counts two errors leading to goals across his England career, along with 46 clean sheets and a 74.3% save ratio. From the start of the 2024-25 season only Arsenal’s David Raya has more league clean sheets than Pickford at Everton.
Former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson spoke up for Pickford before the Spain match. “We saw the last selections and all thought Jordan Pickford’s place is under threat and James Trafford is going to be the next number one. I don’t think Thomas Tuchel saw it as starkly or simply as that,” Robinson said. He went on: “It’s a conversation that will definitely take place down the road, but not now. Jordan is England’s first choice, in my opinion, rightfully so given his consistency and performances over such a long period.”
Robinson added: “This is a debate and conversation for the future definitely because Father Time catches up with everyone eventually and the manager needs to have a contingency plan, but Jordan Pickford very much remains number one and Thomas Tuchel has said as much.” And: “I don’t think Jordan Pickford is under threat for his jersey on a permanent basis any time soon, irrespective of the next selection.”
What Happens Next
Social media filled with the number one argument after the final whistle, and many suggested Madrid marked a changing of the guard. Pickford has faced a keeper battle with his place under pressure before. Tuchel has given no answer yet. England head into the Nations League quarter-finals, and the manager will have to decide who starts there.