Richard Masters Asks 20 Clubs to Pay If City Sponsors Sue Him
Table of Contents
- Premier League chief executive Richard Masters and his four fellow board directors want all 20 clubs to cover their legal costs if City’s sponsors sue them personally, per the Mirror.
- Clubs meet in London on Thursday 19 November, and at least 14 of the 20 must approve the two-page proposal.
- Costs could reach hundreds of millions of pounds, and potentially billions, if a corporate defamation case reaches court.
The Board Wants Clubs, Not Directors, to Carry the Risk of a Sponsor Lawsuit
Richard Masters leads a league board with a gap in its protection. The chief executive and the four other directors on the league board have no indemnity if a company decides to sue them as individuals, and they are about to ask the 20 clubs to supply it. On Thursday 19 November the clubs meet in London to vote on a two-page proposal. If at least 14 of them agree, the clubs would collectively pay the directors’ legal expenses, along with any damages that follow successful legal action from one of City’s principal sponsors or any other third party.
What the Proposal Would Change
The board is Masters, chair Alison Brittain, and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC. None of them has indemnity against third-party claims today. Article 35 of the league’s articles of association reimburses a director’s legal expenses only if they win the case. The new request would have clubs pay the directors’ personal legal bills whatever the outcome.
The document sent to clubs ahead of the meeting makes no mention of City, the club’s sponsors or the 115 charges case. Insiders view it as a response to the legal threat from Etihad Airways. The Premier League says it is always looking to protect the board’s ability to make decisions that are in the best interests of the league and its clubs.
The figures are large. The legal expenses could reach hundreds of millions of pounds, and potentially billions, if a corporate defamation case ever reaches court. Sponsors could also sue outside the UK. Corporate defamation claims in the United States are known to have risen above the billion-pound mark, and there both sides pay their own legal fees whatever the outcome.
How City’s Sponsors Got Involved
The sponsors entered the story with the verdict. An independent commission found City guilty on 114 of 115 charges across the nine seasons from 2009-10 to 2017-18, in a ruling published on 29 September. It described several sponsorship deals as sham arrangements, found that Abu Dhabi United Group, the club’s owner, had topped up fees paid by some commercial sponsors, and concluded that revenues were inflated and costs reduced by more than £900 million. Our earlier report covers the guilty verdict on 114 of 115 charges in full. On the day of the verdict Masters said in a statement: “The core decision establishes the facts of what happened at Manchester City during this period. It details how the club systematically broke Premier League Rules for nearly a decade.”
City were charged in February 2023. They deny any wrongdoing and lodged a full appeal on 1 October. Our earlier report covers City’s window to appeal the verdict.
Etihad Airways, whose name is on City’s shirts and stadium, responded within 24 hours of the verdict. In a statement the airline said: “Etihad categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements.” It added: “At no time did the Premier League reach out to or engage with Etihad in the process associated with the commission’s opinion.” On its next move, it said: “Etihad will seek the relevant legal counsel on the options and recourse available to protect its interests.”
Etisalat, a telecoms company worth more than £40bn, followed on Monday. A company spokesman said: “Emirates Telecommunications Group Company PJSC views the published findings of the English Premier League, as they relate to Etisalat, as entirely false and defamatory. Etisalat is actively considering all options relating to its rights and associated legal remedies in this matter.” Both companies are understood to be holding off on a decision about their next steps.
What Happens Next
The vote on Thursday decides who carries the personal risk: the five directors, or all 20 clubs. If City’s appeal fails, the commission has wide-ranging powers to impose sanctions that run from fines and points deductions to expulsion from the Premier League, and any punishment can also be appealed. The UAE reaction to the verdict is covered in a separate report.