Cuban Tells Pochettino He Is Wrong About Relegation Before Man Utd Debut
Table of Contents
- Mark Cuban, the former majority owner of the Dallas Mavericks, posted on X that Mauricio Pochettino is wrong about relegation and American sports, per talkSPORT.
- Pochettino said in June that “American sports reward losers”, and the comments resurfaced after he left the United States job.
- Cuban argued that promotion and relegation attract buyers chasing a “Relegation Arbitrage” and that the NBA draft already delivers parity.
A Billionaire Answers the Coach Who Just Left America
Mauricio Pochettino left his post as United States head coach after the 2-0 win over Haiti in the CONCACAF Nations League on Tuesday night, and his old comments about American sport resurfaced. Mark Cuban, the billionaire who used to own the majority of the NBA’s Dallas Mavericks, picked them up on X.
“He [Pochettino] is wrong. If you need external motivation to compete, you shouldn’t be on the court/pitch/field, in any capacity,” Cuban posted. “I’m not against relegation. It happens at the bottom of the standings for a reason.”
What Pochettino Said About MLS
The remarks Cuban answered date from June. Pochettino called out Major League Soccer for lacking promotion and relegation, the structure almost every other league in the world uses, and said that “American sports reward losers.”
“If you start in MLS and you haven’t won a game in three months and you’re at the bottom, what’s the consequence if there’s no promotion or relegation, no international competition?” he asked.
He then set out what he sees as the cost. “Soccer is different: if you reward those who don’t win, if you don’t have goals, you don’t fight. If I lose, what happens? Nothing. They just fire the coach.”
His view of the players he coached was mixed. “Also, the American player is disciplined, but with a sense of complacency that isn’t good in soccer,” Pochettino said. “It took us a year and a half to change that mentality.”
Cuban’s Case: Relegation Arbitrage and the Draft
Cuban’s post drew a fair amount of backlash, so he used it to lay out his thinking in more detail. His first point was about money and who relegation attracts.
“I’ll give you another perspective on relegation. Again. Not against it,” Cuban said. “It brings in rich people who will try to buy a team cheap, spend more money than other teams in their league, and look at being promoted, as a business win.
“More revenues. Higher valuation. This is great for the fans whose team they bought .. if they stay committed to winning at the next level. It’s obviously not a new concept. But it’s driving a lot of transactions.
“I get pitched soccer and basketball deals all the time, that are this type of ‘Relegation Arbitrage.’ Not saying it’s right or wrong. Just a reality.”
He also looked at relegation from the players’ side. Stars on a relegated team would probably be moved on for bigger transfer fees and still be paid, he argued, which raised the question of how a league’s economics would change if relegation arrived. In the NBA, he said, a poor record has its own price: people lose their jobs, and players are dealt to other teams for money and cap space flexibility.
His second argument was the draft. “Since I’m having fun talking about this. One key reason why relegation doesn’t work in American sports is because of the draft,” he added. “In Europe they develop players in academies. Sign them younger and younger. Pay transfer fees to try to get better.
“In the NBA a kid can be an obvious superstar, born and loving in Dallas. Coming to Mavs camps. He goes into the draft like everyone. That leads to some level of parity. We have had different champs, and different teams in the finals, for years.
“With some luck. Like getting the number 1 pick. Staying healthy. You can go on a run and win.Put side the math and money, I don’t think we need relegation. It would be a negative in total.”
The Timing Is Awkward for Pochettino
Cuban’s post landed as Pochettino switched jobs. He led the United States to the round of 16 at a home World Cup, a run that under-performed in the eyes of many, and he had signed an extension through 2030 only months earlier. Now he takes over a Manchester United side stuck in a cycle of mediocrity, player fall-out and manager sackings, after the club appointed him as Man Utd manager this month. The coach who asked what the consequence is for losing in a league with no relegation now walks into a club where results have been poor and jobs have gone.
His exit from the American job came with its own talking point, as Pochettino said Guardiola should take the US job if it is offered to him.
His first match in charge is away at Liverpool on Sunday 22 November, and the squad he inherits includes captain Bruno Fernandes, who turned down a second contract offer before Pochettino arrived. A poor start at Anfield would put the relegation argument he made in June back in front of English fans, with Cuban’s reply attached.