Panel Rules Havertz Deserved Penalty as Webb Faces Clubs on Thursday
Table of Contents
- The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents panel ruled six on-field errors in the last round of games, the joint-highest it has recorded in one weekend, per BBC Sport.
- The panel voted 5:0 that Arsenal should have had a penalty when Hull City’s Nobel Mendy pulled back Kai Havertz.
- Howard Webb, the head of Pro Ref, will appear in front of Premier League clubs on Thursday at a routine meeting.
Arsenal Won the Game, but the Panel Says They Were Denied a Penalty
Kai Havertz went down in the Hull City area after Nobel Mendy pulled him back, minutes before half-time, and Arsenal did not get a penalty. Referee Farai Hallam looked at the pitchside monitor after the video assistant, Michael Oliver, sent him there. He stuck with his call and ruled Havertz offside. Arsenal went on to win 1-0 through a late Martin Odegaard goal. Now the Key Match Incidents panel has voted 5:0 that the penalty should have been given. It is the third Arsenal game this season in which the panel has found a wrong penalty call, and the ruling arrives as Webb prepares to face the clubs.
Why an Offside Player Still Earns a Penalty
The laws say that if a foul happens before an offside offence, the foul comes first and a penalty follows. Havertz was in an offside position but had neither played the ball nor interfered with play. The panel put it this way: “Although Havertz is clearly in an offside position, there is a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence by Havertz.”
It added: “Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded. The panel considered the VAR intervention was correct; however, the outcome after the on-field review was considered to be incorrect as a penalty should have been awarded.”
The panel praised the video assistant for asking Hallam to look again. The wrong answer came after the review.
Arsenal’s Other Two Penalty Rulings
Hull is the third Arsenal game to land on the panel’s list. The first came at Sunderland on 12 September, where Arsenal won 2-0 through second-half goals from Bruno Guimaraes and Bukayo Saka. Sunderland had a penalty after Ezri Konsa pulled Dan Ballard to the ground at a corner, and David Raya saved Enzo Le Fee’s kick. The panel ruled the penalty should not have been given: “Although it was a very untidy challenge in which Konsa initially had arms around Ballard, Ballard engages in a holding action which pulls Konsa onto him so they both fall to the floor.”
The second came at the start of November in Arsenal’s 1-0 win over Liverpool. Jurrien Timber pulled back Alexander Isak in the box and no penalty was given. The panel voted 4:1 that referee Andy Madley should have awarded one, and 3:2 that VAR Stuart Attwell should have sent him to the monitor. Its statement read: “The panel felt that a penalty should have been awarded for a holding action by Timber on Isak, 4:1.” It went on: “One panellist considered the short-lived holding to lack clear impact on the ability of Isak to progress. The majority also felt that VAR should have intervened to recommend an on-field review, 3:2, on the basis that it was a clear and obvious error. Two panellists considered that the subjectivity in assessing impact meant this did not meet the high threshold for VAR intervention.” We covered the panel’s Isak penalty ruling when it came out.
A Week of Rulings Against the Referees
Havertz was one of six on-field errors the panel logged. You have to go back to the early part of the 2023-24 season to find the last time it recorded that many in a round.
Coventry City were denied a penalty on the Friday when Everton’s James Tarkowski pulled Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair. The panel’s ruling: “Tarkowski had a hold of Yirenkyi’s hair and the panel unanimously felt that VAR should have intervened.” Last season that incident would likely have meant a straight red card, but the guidance changed this term and red cards for hair pulling now need excessive force.
Crystal Palace were given a late penalty against Liverpool for a clash between Milos Kerkez and Dario Osorio. The panel voted 0:5 that the award was wrong, and 5:0 that VAR was right to stay out of it: “A penalty was incorrect with the contact being inevitable. However, it was not a clear and obvious error.”
The Panel, the Pay and the Meeting on Thursday
Five people sit on the panel: a representative from the Premier League and Pro Ref, plus three former managers or players. It meets after every round, and this is the first season its findings are public. The votes feed a merit table that contributes to 50% of referees’ salaries in bonus payments, so the verdicts reach the referees’ pay.
Webb, who backed VAR in October, faces the clubs on Thursday. He can tell them VAR delays are down this season after the bar for intervention was raised.
Arsenal lead the Premier League after 10 games. They travel to Newcastle United on Saturday 21 November.