Neville Calls Dalot an Easy Target and Names Three Defenders to Sell

Gary Neville highlights commencement ceremony for Sport Spot Academy Shanghai 92 - Gary Neville ‘Not Surprised’ A
Gary Neville highlights commencement ceremony for Sport Spot Academy Shanghai 92 - Gary Neville ‘Not Surprised’ A
  • Gary Neville says Diogo Dalot is an easy target and would move on Mazraoui, Martinez and De Ligt before him, per Daily Mail.
  • Neville expects Mauricio Pochettino to keep Shaw, Maguire, Yoro and Dalot to start with.
  • Neville says the first wave of changes comes at the end of the season, with one or two defenders in January if possible.

Why Neville Would Move On Three Defenders Before Dalot

Gary Neville has come to the defence of Diogo Dalot, and he has named three Manchester United defenders he would move on first. He made his case on the Stick to United podcast on Tuesday. Dalot, a Portugal international, has faced heavy scrutiny this season as Michael Carrick’s side declined through the autumn. With Mauricio Pochettino about to take over at Old Trafford, Neville urged the new manager not to throw Dalot out straight away, whatever the dip in his form.

An Easy Target in a Weak Back Four

“I think if he was in a decent back four he’d be alright,” Neville told Stick to United co-host Mark Goldbridge on Tuesday. “But he’s got a shocking back four alongside him.”

“Positionally he’s not great. He could be better on the ball. He could be better at everything he does. Of course he could. I just think he’s such an easy target, Dalot. I honestly do.”

Neville admitted that he sometimes listens to Manchester United supporting friends running Dalot down and wonders “are they watching something that I don’t see?”

The Three Names Neville Wants Gone

The three he would let go in the first wave of changes are Noussair Mazraoui, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt.

“I’d be getting (Noussair) Mazraoui well gone before him,” he continued. “I’d be getting (Lisandro) Martinez gone well before him. I’ll be getting (Matthijs) De Ligt gone well before him.”

“(De Ligt has) got one big problem. He doesn’t play football. If a player is injury prone and doesn’t play football, just because he hasn’t played doesn’t mean to say that he should go above a player who’s played every single week and he’s throwing his hand up. You want someone who’s actually reliable and play. De Ligt has to go. De Ligt, Martinez, Mazraoui.”

Martinez has been a difficult presence in the squad this season. He criticised the club hierarchy in an interview last month, implied he was unhappy with the summer recruitment strategy, and had to hold clear-the-air talks to smooth his return to the side.

Who Stays Under Pochettino

Neville expects Pochettino to keep Luke Shaw, Harry Maguire, Leny Yoro and Dalot, at least to start with. On Shaw he sees an injury problem that will force the new manager to buy a left back as well.

“He will keep Shaw because he knows him and he’ll probably get the best out of him. The problem with Luke is injuries,” he added. “So he’ll have to manage him. So he’ll have to bring a left back in. But let’s just say who he’ll keep.”

“He’ll keep Shaw. He’ll keep (Harry) Maguire because he’ll trust him and he’ll think that he’s basically a soldier and someone who can do a job for him.”

Maguire has been mentoring Heaven and Yoro this season, and Yoro drew the most detailed assessment from Neville.

“He’ll keep (Leny) Yoro because I think he’ll think “I’ve got something there that I can work with”. (But) I think he’s a little bit gangly, all over the place right now. And he looks like he’s going to slip every time. He’s got that sort of Bambi-on-ice (look).”

“Physically what will happen is with Yoro, he’ll go one way or the other. I like the fact he’s been brought into the French team. It tells me sometimes you just have got to connect the dots and think, “okay, well, if they think he’s good, then we must be missing something here because we’re not seeing it yet, are we?”.”

Neville added that Yoro lacks a connection within his body that Jeremy Jacquet already uses, something Sir Alex Ferguson spotted in Rio Ferdinand at West Ham, and he backed Yoro to flourish as his strength and stability improve. He would also loan Ayden Heaven to a lower division club to build up his game, and thinks it is borderline unfair to be putting him in the side at present.

Pochettino Has Little Time

“So Yoro he will keep: Yoro, Maguire and Shaw I think he’ll keep and I think he’ll keep Dalot. To start with,” Neville said. “He’ll have to bring in three defenders to go above them. Let’s be clear. He’ll have to bring in three defenders.”

“Mazraoui I would lose, De Ligt I would lose because he’s injury prone. Martinez 100 per cent. 100 per cent. 100 per cent.”

Not every change can come quickly. Pochettino has little time before he takes charge of United against Liverpool at Anfield this weekend.

“First wave, end of the season,” Neville clarified of what he believes Pochettino’s plan for change will be. “No, he can’t get rid of (them all) in January.”

“He has to bring one or two defenders in January if he can. But he can’t get rid of all those in his first wave. He’s only got one month till January.”

How Pochettino Ended Up at Old Trafford

Neville has already weighed in on Carrick’s treatment and on what Pochettino should demand from the club. The process of removing Carrick began last week, when Jason Wilcox and Omar Berrada flew to Monaco for talks with co-owners Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazer ownership group. Carrick was sacked last Thursday, and Pochettino was appointed days later.

What Happens Next

Pochettino inherits a defence that Neville thinks needs three new faces and a patient plan. Dalot, who has faced heavy criticism from supporters, has a high profile defender heading into the Liverpool game. Whether Pochettino agrees will show in his team selection at Anfield.

WRITTEN BY

George Howson

George Howson is a Futbol Chronicle contributor and accredited journalist with over 20 years of experience following international football. A member of the AIPS International Sports Press Association, George has covered matches at stadiums around the world, bringing deep knowledge and first-hand insight to every match report and analysis he writes.

More articles by George Howson →

Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment






The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

More in News

Rooney, 41, Credits Coleen After Two-Day Drinking Sessions at His Career Peak

Wayne Rooney, 41, says he drank in his games room ...
Mauricio Pochettino

Pochettino Says Guardiola Should Take His US Job Before Man Utd Debut

Mauricio Pochettino told reporters on Monday that Pep Guardiola should ...
ISTANBUL, TURKEY - OCTOBER 27: Jorge Jesus, Head Coach of Fenerbahce speaks to the media in the post match press conference after their sides draw the UEFA Europa League group B match between Fenerbahce and Stade Rennes at Ulker Sukru Saracoglu Stadium on October 27, 2022 in Istanbul, Turkey. (Photo by Francois Nel - UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)

Piers Morgan Calls Jorge Jesus a Clown Over His Answer on Ronaldo

Piers Morgan called Portugal coach Jorge Jesus a clown on ...
TALLINN, ESTONIA - JUNE 09: Martin Odegaard of Norway is challenged by Patrik Kristal of Estonia during the FIFA 2026 Qualifier between Estonia and Norway at A. Le Coq Arena on June 09, 2025 in Tallinn, Estonia. (Photo by Ville Vuorinen - UEFA/UEFA via Getty Images)

Odegaard Played 90 Minutes for Norway After Vomiting All Night, Says Solbakken

Martin Odegaard played the full 90 minutes of Norway's 3-1 ...

Gerrard Thinks Pochettino’s Spanish Beat Eddie Howe for the Man Utd Job

Steven Gerrard believes Mauricio Pochettino's Spanish helped him win the ...

Trending on Futbol Chronicle

Premier League

Map of All the Premier League Teams for 2025/26

The 2025/26 Premier League features 20 clubs spread across England, ...
Michael Carrick - Rooney says Carrick gave “taste of what it was like under Sir Alex Ferguson”

Michael Carrick points to lack of sharpness after Manchester United draw with West Ham

• Michael Carrick cited a lack of sharpness after Manchester ...

Celta Vigo postpones LaLiga opener after fungus outbreak damages stadium pitch

Celta Vigo’s LaLiga opener against Osasuna has been postponed because ...
CHORZOW, POLAND - OCTOBER 11, 2018: Football Nations League division A group 3 match Poland vs Portugal 2:3 . In the picture assistant of referee. — Stock Editorial Photography

What Is Offsides in Soccer? The Offside Rule Fully Explained

A player is offside if any part of their head, ...

Why Soccer Is The Best Sport

Soccer has become incredibly popular across the globe in recent ...