Maresca Says Haaland’s 24th Minute Goal Was No Foul but Leno Disagrees
Table of Contents
- Manchester City striker Erling Haaland had a 24th minute equaliser against Fulham ruled out for a foul on goalkeeper Bernd Leno, per Sky Sports.
- City head coach Enzo Maresca reviewed the goal after the game and says it was not a foul, while Leno says it was.
- The Premier League says VAR checked the referee’s call and confirmed that Leno was in control of the ball.
Did Leno Have the Ball Under Control?
Enzo Maresca reviewed Erling Haaland’s disallowed goal after the game and reached a verdict. “I reviewed the goal after the game and from my point of view it is quite clear that it is not a foul but I am not the guy who decides, unfortunately.” The Manchester City head coach said Haaland was sure of it too. “[Erling] was absolutely sure even when they were reviewing the VAR that it is a goal because I asked from the touchline but the referee decides differently.” The goal came in the 24th minute at the Etihad on Saturday, with Fulham a goal ahead. Leno disagrees with Maresca, the Premier League backs the referee and the pundits cannot settle it.
What happened at the back post
Rodrigo Muniz had put Fulham in front in the 16th minute. In the 24th, Iliman Ndiaye’s cross found Haaland at the back post. Leno got his hands to the ball, and Haaland jabbed at the goalkeeper, nudging it through his grasp and into the net. The referee’s watch flashed to signal a goal, then referee Thomas Bramall ruled a foul on Leno instead. VAR did not overrule him.
The Premier League Match Centre explained the decision on social media. “The referee’s call of free-kick to Fulham and no goal to Manchester City was checked and confirmed by VAR – with the goalkeeper deemed to be in control of the ball.” It added what the VAR said. “The ball is in control between both hands and then is played out of that possession by the attacker, and then into the back of the net.”
The Laws of the Game treat a goalkeeper as in control of the ball when it is “between their hands/arms or between their hand(s)/arm(s) and any surface”. That wording is the whole argument. Whether Leno had the ball under control, or whether Haaland knocked it out of an unsettled grasp, is where the two sides part.
Leno and Arbeloa back the call
Leno told his side of it after the game. “I had the feeling I controlled the ball and Haaland crashed into me and slid into me. It was a wet pitch. I was hoping VAR doesn’t overturn it. For me it was a foul.”
Fulham head coach Alvaro Arbeloa was asked about the decision and pointed to his goalkeeper. “Leno told me that, Haaland, it was a foul so I prefer not to talk about the referee and the yellow cards because last time I spoke about the referee it wasn’t good for me, I need to save money so I prefer to talk about my players.”
Pundits and fans split
Former Arsenal and Chelsea midfielder Karen Carney said the replay changed her mind. “My initial reaction was I thought the goalkeeper didn’t have control of it, and it should’ve been a goal, but then when you slow it down, (you can see it).” She went on to say she expected an argument. “People are going to shout at me through the TV. But I think the referee made the right decision.”
Tottenham legend Glenn Hoddle was working in Manchester and felt the same, though he called it close. “I don’t know whether he had control of it, but I don’t think that comes into it. I think that’s the right decision, but it’s a very tough call. It could have gone either way.”
Supporters were split too. On X, an Arsenal fan wrote: “Even as a rival, I honestly think this Haaland goal should’ve stood for Manchester City. Would’ve been p***** off if a Gyokeres goal like this for Arsenal was cancelled.” A different fan added: “Manchester City has been robbed. Haaland scored a clean goal here. The ball went in even before Haaland had contact with the keeper.”
Others took the opposite view. One said: “It’s explicitly a foul under the Laws. Don’t blame the ref if you don’t like the laws.” Another user wrote: “I am also an Arsenal fan but the ball is still in two-palm contact. If you allow it, you will encourage outfield player challenging the save attempt And a foot to hand challenge will much more often lead to a broken wrist or thumb. That is an unfair advantage to outfield players.”
What comes next for City
The row sits on top of a poor run. City are winless in four league games, and this draw only ended a three-game losing streak. Elliot Anderson volleyed a cleared corner into the bottom corner from 18 yards to level it in the second half, but the home fans booed at the final whistle. Haaland, normally clinical, missed a number of fine chances, and Fulham were well worth a point. Fulham had not avoided defeat against City at any point from September 2011 until this game, and City have now conceded in nine consecutive games in all competitions, a run they last matched in 2019. They are also waiting to learn the consequences of being found guilty of financial breaches.
City were on the other side of a VAR argument in September, when Pro Ref admitted that VAR should have sent Haaland’s Manchester derby winner to an on-field review. The decision at the Etihad stands, and the wording of the Laws backs the officials if Leno had both hands on the ball, which is what VAR said he had. Maresca and Leno looked at the same contact and reached opposite verdicts. City host Napoli in the Champions League on Tuesday 24 November, then visit Arsenal in the Premier League.