Mainoo Says “No Chance” on Yoro’s Red as Neville Backs the Referee
Table of Contents
- Kobbie Mainoo said “no chance” when asked whether Leny Yoro’s eighth minute red card at Anfield was the right call, per Sky Sports.
- Gary Neville and Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola backed the sending off, while Bruno Fernandes and Roy Keane said Alexander Isak was never getting the ball.
- Mauricio Pochettino, in his first game as Manchester United manager, called the red card unfair and said a sixth minute challenge on Bryan Mbeumo was a penalty.
A Heavy Touch Left Yoro’s Red Card Open to Argument
Kobbie Mainoo, 21, was asked whether Leny Yoro deserved to be sent off after eight minutes of Manchester United’s 4-0 defeat at Liverpool. The midfielder was blunt.
“The game’s been taken out of our hands by a red card that I don’t think can be a red card,” Mainoo said.
“No chance. The ball’s already with the goalkeeper. They’re both running full speed. What can we do? It is what it is.”
What the officials had to weigh
Ronald Araujo sent a long ball forward and Matthijs de Ligt, playing his first Premier League minutes of the season, misjudged its flight. Isak ran through, took a heavy touch, and Yoro brought him down just outside the box as the last defender. Referee Sam Barrott gave the foul and the red card straight away, and the decision stood after VAR, with John Brooks as the video official. It was United’s earliest red card in the Premier League.
Isak was running directly at goal in a central position with no covering defender. The one open question was the likelihood of keeping or gaining control of the ball. His touch came before Yoro’s contact, so the challenge did not cause him to overrun it. Barrott and Brooks had to decide whether Isak would definitely have reached the ball ahead of goalkeeper Senne Lammens. If there is any doubt, the sanction is a yellow card.
Mainoo, Pochettino and Fernandes say it was wrong
Mainoo, who signed a long-term contract until 2031 in April, made his feelings clear right after the final whistle.
“Absolutely no chance Leny Yoro’s challenge was a red card. Never. The ball was already with the keeper, they’re both running full speed, what can he do?” he said.
“It’s 10 vs 11, you come to a place like Anfield, it’s a tough game anyway. Then you lose a man, it makes it hard. I can’t fault the boys for their fight in the game. We take the pain and move on.”
“I wouldn’t say it all goes out the window. You can still take the things you did in training into the game, but it makes it 10 times harder with one less man in a situation like that.”
“So painful. So disappointed,” Pochettino said. “It’s not ok to start a game in the Premier League with this situation.”
“The game changed completely after six minutes. Now we can explain everything but the damage is done, it’s so painful.”
“The players are so, so feeling the pain of the result. I told them to be calm: it was an unfair situation that happened. We need to accept that reality. We need to try to increase our focus, concentration and make better decisions on the field.”
“We also need to be critical on ourselves but some situations happened in the game that we are not happy.”
Asked about Isak’s heavy touch, the United manager said: “The ball was for the goalkeeper.”
“In that situation, if you review the VAR you can see for sure, [Yoro] never had the intention to connect with Isak. When the control was long with the striker, the ball was going to the goalkeeper, he runs and goes down.”
“In Leny’s case, it wasn’t intentional.”
He pointed to the other end, where Jeremy Jacquet had challenged Mbeumo.
“If you look before, on the sixth minute. Jacquet on Mbeumo. Similar? No. If you compare the actions, that was a penalty.”
“How that changes life, if you score after six minutes. Now, for sure, we are talking in a different way. We have to take responsibility, I take the responsibility. We keep pushing.”
“It’s difficult to accept that because it was a foul under my view and for me was a penalty,” Pochettino said.
“Look how everything changes if that action was a red card and a foul, I think we need to review. When I played football that situation is normal. The action against Mbeumo, if that [Yoro foul on Isak] was a red card then that was a penalty.”
Pochettino spoke to the officials at full time and was asked about it: “It’s not going to change what happened. Being respectful is the most important.”
“At the same time, I have to defend my club. And tell what I feel. That was an action that everyone who plays football, it was clear that a situation that was not a red card.”
Pochettino came back to the Jacquet challenge when the questions turned to De Ligt.
“And I repeat again, Jacquet was a penalty, and if the referee says that is a penalty, for sure that action after never comes, and maybe we talk in another way.”
“But, you know, one centre-back made a mistake, was penalty, wasn’t punished, and us, we made one mistake and we were punished. And now I accept all the situation, but the circumstance are the circumstance.”
“It’s so important to put the circumstance in front. Always.”
When it was put to him that United did not have to concede four goals after the sending off, Pochettino answered at length.
“It’s so easy to talk in this way.”
“It’s about the team, always it’s about balance. It’s not about one line, the defensive line, the midfield, the offensive. I think when the team concede it is because the balance is not so good, and that I take responsibility about that.”
“It’s still a lot of games to play. We are in the reality and we need to accept the reality and we need to be responsible and we need to be united, we need to be all together. And I think we feel disappointed because it’s clear. It’s clear that after eight minutes, it happened what happened, and I think all that the plan was in the bin.”
“And what I learn from my players is that they like to fight, they are committed with the team, with the club, and of course they want to win games, they want to make the effort, and I think today we made an unbelievable effort.”
“I think today was a test. That for me is very positive. After eight minutes, 10 men, red card, concede the goal in this action, Szoboszlai that scored from a free-kick, and 80 minutes to play, more than 80 minutes because I think, you know, the injury time and everything. Do you think that is easy?”
“Even the best team in the world playing like this in this situation, in our circumstance, maybe concede the four goals or maybe more. And now what we are going to say? We are in a situation that this is very complicated, it’s difficult, yes, but I think we fight, we made the effort.”
Captain Bruno Fernandes said the decision should be reviewed.
“It’s one that needs to be looked at,” Fernandes said.
“We have far too many meetings with the referees for this to happen to us again. The last one against Chelsea [when Lisandro Martinez was sent off], you can give it as a red card and it was probably a second yellow also. Today, you can’t give a red card.”
“It’s very clear they show us if the player is not in control of the ball, it’s never a red card.”
“Isak kicks the ball forward, the ball goes into the hands of Senne. Isak has got no control of the ball, he has no chance to get on the ball. He puts his leg across to try to get some advantage from Leny. I can understand the fall, but it’s never a red card.”
“There are too many referees on the pitch and too many on VAR taking so long to see to make a mistake like this that can change the game.”
“It’s not because of them we conceded the goal from the free-kick, but it changes the game completely.”
Neville and Iraola back it, Keane does not
Gary Neville, a former United defender who told Pochettino to demand control of recruitment earlier this month, backed the decision. Danny Murphy, a pundit on Match of the Day, said there was “no doubt” about the red card.
“Leny Yoro has to cover and he doesn’t,” Neville said. “He reacts late and his anticipation is poor.”
“It’s so clumsy from Yoro. It’s naivety, he just needs to get off the pitch. You’re not going to get that turned around, no chance.”
Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola saw no debate at all.
“I think he’s the last man, no?” he said. “It’s a clear foul and a red card, yes?”
Roy Keane, Neville’s former teammate, disagreed while still criticising United’s defending.
“Isak’s not getting the ball,” Keane said. “There’s no way he’s getting the ball.”
“It’s clumsy from United. Obviously it’s one straight ball over the top. You shouldn’t be in so much trouble.”
“But there’s no way he’s getting that ball. Absolutely not. I know Isak is quick and he’s sharp, but we’ve looked at it again.”
“It’s really poor defending. Players not smelling danger. But Isak is not getting that ball. Absolutely not.”
The precedent, and what comes next
Brighton’s Pascal Struijk was sent off at Sunderland after a VAR review for bringing down Wilson Isidor, and Brighton won their appeal as there was clear doubt that Isidor would have controlled the ball. The Football Association regulatory commission ruled unanimously that the red card was wrong, yet the Premier League’s key match incidents panel voted 3-2 that the VAR call was correct. In another case, Ipswich’s Issa Diop avoided a VAR red card for a foul on James McAtee against Nottingham Forest when referee Thomas Bramall disagreed with the video official. Bramall refereed both games. Whether United will follow Brighton’s route is not yet known.
Gravenberch’s red card against City set off another referee row for Liverpool in October. United sit second from bottom, and Victor Munoz’s goal in the 82nd minute took them to 34 conceded in all competitions, the worst defence in Europe’s top five leagues. Mainoo finished by looking ahead.
“It’s hard, it’s painful. But no one’s coming to save us. We have to work hard, keep digging, keep working, keep fighting. It will all come round.”